Bay Shore, New York

Bay Shore Property Management

Our virtual management team handles leasing, rent collection, maintenance coordination, and owner visibility for a flat monthly fee.

Start 14 day free trial

We'll help make your Bay Shore investment a home

Bay Shore, New York is a vibrant community located on the south shore of Long Island. According to the US Census, the population of Bay Shore was estimated to be 28,948 in 2021. This bustling town is home to a variety of businesses, restaurants, and recreational activities. With its close proximity to the beach, Bay Shore is a popular destination for tourists and locals alike. The town also offers a variety of educational opportunities, with several public and private schools in the area. Bay Shore is a great place to live, work, and play.

Bay Shore Rental Market Overview

cityaverage pricepct difference
East Hampton$9,003184.2%
Nyack$3,2121.4%
Tarrytown$3,1920.8%
Bay Shore$3,1670.0%
Douglaston$3,151-0.5%
Briarwood$2,291-27.7%
Montgomery$1,984-37.3%
Menands$1,913-39.6%
Port Jervis$1,709-46.1%
Carmel Hamlet$1,548-51.1%
Brighton$1,394-56.0%

Serving top neighborhoods in Bay Shore

1. Brightwaters: Located on the Great South Bay, Brightwaters is a small village in the Town of Islip in Suffolk County, New York. It is known for its quaint, tree-lined streets, beautiful homes, and excellent schools. It is also home to the Brightwaters Canal, a popular spot for fishing and boating.

2. West Bay Shore: West Bay Shore is a neighborhood in the Town of Islip in Suffolk County, New York. It is known for its beautiful homes, excellent schools, and convenient access to the Great South Bay. It is also home to the Bay Shore Marina, a popular spot for fishing and boating.

3. South Bay Shore: South Bay Shore is a neighborhood in the Town of Islip in Suffolk County, New York. It is known for its beautiful homes, excellent schools, and convenient access to the Great South Bay. It is also home to the Bay Shore Marina, a popular spot for fishing and boating.

4. North Bay Shore: North Bay Shore is a neighborhood in the Town of Islip in Suffolk County, New York. It is known for its beautiful homes, excellent schools, and convenient access to the Great South Bay. It is also home to the Bay Shore Marina, a popular spot for fishing and boating.

5. East Bay Shore: East Bay Shore is a neighborhood in the Town of Islip in Suffolk County, New York. It is known for its beautiful homes, excellent schools, and convenient access to the Great South Bay. It is also home to the Bay Shore Marina, a popular spot for fishing and boating.